Wow, I didn't know it was a crime to not love Willow. She's not my favorite either, but I like her better in the early years than the later ones. Season One Willow is very much like how I was in high school, so I relate. It was nice to see someone like me portrayed in a positive manner on TV. Plus she's with Oz in the early seasons. :)

My favorites are Spike and Anya. I was very unhappy with Xander when he left her at the altar, and then the way she was just so quickly killed in season 7, almost like she was an afterthought and not important enough for a meaningful death scene. Blink and you missed it. I thought that was really uncool too.