
Once upon a time, I watched a fair amount of TV and fell in love with three different actresses for very different shows. There was Alyssa Milano on Who's The Boss?, there was Shannen Doherty on Beverly Hills, 90210 as well as Our House (and let us never forget the perfect movie that was Heathers), and Holly Marie Combs in Picket Fences.
Now. Imagine my sheer, unadulterated glee at realizing all three would be in the same show and it would be about witches? I'm pretty sure if you listen carefully, you can still hear younger!me squeeing about it even now. Yes, that high pitched shriek that's been bothering you for more than 20 years at this point is me shrieking at a show pretty much perfectly tailored to me. Later that joy will turn to bitterness but let's not dwell on that. Nope.
( Oh, do go on, self. You're so interesting. )
Enough preamble. Let's get onto the rewatch.
Honestly, the pilot is a good, solid episode. It's not earth shattering and awesome and something that sets up the series for failure to live up to that initial promise, but it's also not "sweet baby Jesus, what did I just watch?" I still remember the feeling I had after first watching it and thinking that while it wasn't AH-MAZING I wanted to know more and the wait might kill me.
Charmed has always worked best when it focused on the sisters who are witches not witches who are sisters angle and the pilot exemplifies this.
( Recap. )
A lot of things work for Something Wicca This Way Comes. It's not painfully dated in anything other than fashion and currently the 90's are having a comeback so even that's not a big thing. The sisters are realistic in their squabbles. Prue versus Phoebe feels real and so does their attempt at bonding after the pharmacy fiasco. Piper's ability to be friends with both works and I like her acknowledgment that she and Phoebe had things easier as kids than Prue did. It sets Prue up to be a bit more standoffish, but it's clear that she and Piper are close considering they had an apartment together. Romantic history is hinted at in various ways for all three sisters, from Piper's easy going romance with Jeremy, to Prue's spark for Andy, and let us not forget the PITA that is Roger for both Phoebe and Prue.
On the powers front, I relate so freaking hardcore to Phoebe. While both Piper and Prue lament not being normal anymore, Phoebe is practically dancing in the street at the idea of not being normal, at being something more than she was yesterday. She's super into her birthright and she immediately throws herself into research mode. I won't say I forgot how much I loved early Phoebe, because I knew... and it's part of why I have so many problems with her characterization in the later seasons. S1 Phoebe is snarky, defensive, and abrasive at times, but she also wants to be better and to be more. She wants to earn her place back in her family and if she gets to learn some interesting family history along the way, all the better.
The show also sets up things that will later pay off. Andy's suspicions about the cat and what it means that the Halliwells have it, Morris being dragged into the occult whether he wants to be or not, Melinda Warren, and even their father issues even if that one is going to be something I will rant about until the day I die. Also, the running theme of all three sisters having less than stellar luck in love, though I do think it's adorable that the morning after Piper's boyfriend nearly kills her remaining family, she's still the one to tell Prue that not only do witches date, they get the best guys. Is it because she's a hopeless romantic? Well, yes, but also she knows that Prue needs a push towards Andy and goddamn it, I'm sucked right back in.
Yes, its probably best not to look too hard at the attempt at Wicca and I should mention that the special effects are probably dated as well, but they were then too so eh. Jeremy's handing of the athame while trying to menace Piper is laughably bad and I kind of wish we'd gotten the reveal about Jeremy later on in the series... but not really because just looking at him you knew he was a bad guy.
The magic works because the underlying sisterhood works and while I probably wouldn't list this episode as my favorite, it's definitely worth a watch.
( Quotes and nitpicks and things to keep an eye out for in the future. )
See you next week for I've Got You Under My Skin. You can watch along on Netflix or pick up the DVDs for insanely cheap considering the remastered version is coming out at the end of the month.